When Love Isn’t Love: Understanding Codependency, Toxic Attraction, and the Psychology of Chasing Rejection

Why we confuse suffering with devotion — and what’s really going on beneath the surface.


A loving relationship and a codependent relationship can look similar on the surface: both may involve deep care, intense feelings, and a strong desire to stay connected. But psychologically, they function very differently, and the impact on wellbeing is not the same.

This article will explore two questions:

  • Why codependency is not the same as a loving relationship.
  • Why some people feel deeply attached to, or keep pursuing, people who treat them badly or clearly do not want a relationship with them.

1. Why codependency is not the same as a loving relationship

What healthy love looks like

In a healthy relationship, both partners matter. Each person’s needs, feelings, values, and boundaries are acknowledged and respected. Both individuals can be close and emotionally connected, while still maintaining their own sense of self, independence, and life outside the relationship.

Core features of a healthy relationship include:

  • Mutual respect: Each partner recognises the other as a separate person, with their own thoughts, preferences, and limits.
  • Open communication: Difficult topics can be discussed without constant fear of conflict, abandonment, or retaliation.
  • Emotional safety: Both partners feel safe to be honest, vulnerable, and imperfect.
  • Healthy boundaries: Time alone, time with friends, hobbies, and work are allowed and supported, not treated as threats.
  • Shared responsibility: Both partners contribute to problem-solving, decision-making, and emotional support.

In this type of relationship, care and support flow in both directions. Neither person is required to “rescue” or “fix” the other in order to feel valuable or loved.

What codependency is:

Codependency is not simply “loving too much” or “being very caring.” It is a pattern where one person’s self-worth and emotional stability become excessively dependent on another person’s mood, behaviour, or approval. The relationship becomes less about connection and more about control, caretaking, or clinging.

Common signs of codependency include:

  • Over-focusing on the other person’s feelings and problems, while ignoring your own.
  • Feeling responsible for keeping the other person happy, calm, or functional.
  • Difficulty saying no, setting limits, or expressing your own needs.
  • Guilt or anxiety when you prioritise yourself.
  • Staying in relationships that are one-sided, disrespectful, or even harmful, because leaving feels unbearable.
  • Defining your identity primarily through the relationship (“I don’t know who I am without them”).

These patterns often develop in childhood. For example, growing up with a parent who was emotionally unpredictable, neglectful, or struggling with mental health or addiction can lead a child to take on a caregiving role. That child may learn that being “good,” helpful, or invisible is the only way to maintain connection. As an adult, this can show up as codependency: choosing partners who need rescuing, minimising one’s own needs, and confusing self-sacrifice with love.

The key differences in simple terms

Although both healthy love and codependency can be intense, their foundations are different.

AreaHealthy loveCodependency
Sense of self“I am me, you are you, and we choose each other.”“I am okay only if you are okay and stay with me.”
BoundariesClear, respected, flexibleBlurred, ignored, or feel dangerous to set
Motivation to helpCare, respect, teamworkFear of rejection, guilt, or need to be needed
Emotional balanceGenerally stable, even when stressedHigh anxiety, emotional highs and lows
ResponsibilityShared responsibility for the relationshipOne person carries most of the emotional load

A useful way to think about it is this:


Healthy love allows both people to grow. Codependency requires one person to shrink.


2. Why people appear to love those who treat them badly

Many clients ask some version of this question:

“Why do I feel so attached to someone who hurts me, ignores me, or clearly doesn’t want me? What is wrong with me?”

Nothing is “wrong” with you for wanting love and connection. The difficulty usually lies in how your nervous system, beliefs, and past experiences have wired you to recognise (and sometimes chase) certain types of relationships.

Several psychological processes commonly play a role.

Attachment patterns from childhood

Early relationships with parents or caregivers form an invisible “template” for how love feels and how relationships work.

If love in childhood was:

  • inconsistent (sometimes warm, sometimes rejecting),
  • conditional (“I love you when you behave, succeed, or please me”), or
  • intertwined with criticism, neglect, or chaos,

then part of you may have learned that love is something you must earn, chase, or work very hard to keep.

As an adult, this can lead to:

  • Choosing partners who are emotionally unavailable, critical, or unpredictable.
  • Feeling intense attraction to people who give mixed signals.
  • Experiencing anxiety and panic when a partner pulls away, even if they are not treating you well.

Your mind and body may be drawn not to what is healthy, but to what is familiar.

Intermittent reinforcement and “trauma bonding”

When someone treats you badly most of the time, but occasionally offers warmth, affection, or attention, your brain can become stuck in a powerful cycle. The rare moments of kindness feel especially intense and meaningful, because they are unpredictable.

This pattern is called intermittent reinforcement. It is the same principle that makes gambling addictive. The “maybe this time” feeling can keep a person emotionally hooked far beyond what seems logical.

When this cycle of hurt and reward is repeated, especially in the context of a close relationship, it can create what is sometimes called a trauma bond. The person being mistreated may:

  • Feel unable to leave, even when they know the relationship is harmful.
  • Focus on the “good moments” and minimise the bad.
  • Believe the mistreating partner is the only one who truly understands them.
  • Feel an almost addictive pull back to the relationship after any separation.

This is not a sign of weakness; it is a predictable response of the nervous system to cycles of threat and relief.

Repetition of old emotional wounds

Another dynamic often at play is an unconscious attempt to “rewrite” earlier experiences. If, for example, you felt unwanted, unseen, or “not good enough” as a child, you may be drawn to partners who evoke similar feelings. Part of you is hoping that this time, if you work hard enough, the person will finally choose you, stay, or treat you well.

Psychologically, this can feel like:

  • “If I can get this person to love me, it will prove I am worthy.”
  • “If I can fix this relationship, it will undo all of the hurt I’ve carried for years.”

Unfortunately, the people we pick in these situations are often the least likely to give us what we need. Instead of healing the wound, the same pattern is repeated.


3. Why some people keep pursuing someone who clearly doesn’t want a relationship

It can be especially confusing when a person continues to chase a relationship even after the other party has made it plain — either through words or behaviour — that they do not want to be involved.

Several factors often overlap here.

The pull of uncertainty and fantasy

When someone is consistently kind, available, and clear, the relationship can feel safe but less “dramatic.” When someone is inconsistent or rejecting, the mind may become preoccupied with questions like:

  • “What did I do wrong?”
  • “What if I just try one more time?”
  • “Maybe they are scared, maybe they are confused, maybe I can show them.”

The focus shifts from, “Do I want this person?” to, “How do I get this person?”


The other person becomes less of a real human with flaws, and more of a symbol: proof of worth, a challenge to be solved, or a fantasy of who they could be “if only…”

This inner story can be very compelling, even when their behaviour is telling a different truth.

Low self-esteem and fear of being alone

If deep down you feel unworthy, unlovable, or “too much,” you may unconsciously place the other person on a pedestal. Their approval becomes a substitute for your own self-acceptance. Walking away may feel like admitting that all your fears about yourself are true.

Fear of being alone can intensify this:

  • Being alone may feel frightening, empty, or shameful.
  • The current pursuit, even if painful, at least feels familiar and gives a sense of purpose.

In this state, the idea of letting go can feel more threatening than continuing to chase someone who does not want to be caught.

The “sunk cost” feeling

After investing a lot of time, emotion, and effort into someone, it can feel unbearable to walk away. A common thought is, “I’ve put so much into this; I can’t give up now.” This is sometimes called the sunk cost effect: continuing with something primarily because of what has already been invested, rather than what is actually happening now.

In relationships, this can sound like:

  • “We’ve been doing this for years; surely they will come around.”
  • “If I leave now everything I’ve done will have been for nothing.”

The difficulty is that staying does not recover the past. It only shapes the future.


4. Moving toward healthier patterns

If you recognise yourself in these descriptions, you are not alone. Many people who seek therapy at Feel Good Psychology & Counselling share similar experiences: staying in painful relationships, confusing intensity with love, or feeling unable to stop pursuing someone who does not truly choose them.

Some steps that can help include:

  • Building awareness
    Gently noticing your patterns — without harsh self-judgment — is a powerful first step. Naming codependency, attachment wounds, or trauma bonding does not define you; it simply helps explain what is happening.
  • Reassessing what “love” means
    It can be useful to ask: “If I removed the drama, the chasing, and the anxiety, what would be left in this connection?” Healthy love tends to feel steady, respectful, and safe, even if it is not always exciting or perfect.
  • Reconnecting with your own needs and values
    Many people in codependent or pursuing roles have lost touch with questions like:
    “What do I want?”, “What makes me feel alive, fulfilled, and respected?”
    Therapy can provide a structured space to explore these questions and rebuild a sense of self that is not dependent on another person’s approval.
  • Learning and practising boundaries
    Setting limits — for example, reducing contact, saying no, or walking away from disrespect — can feel uncomfortable if you are used to self-sacrifice. With support, these skills can become core tools for protecting emotional health.
  • Processing past experiences
    Working through earlier relationship wounds, including those from childhood or previous partners, can reduce the pull to repeat the same patterns. As those wounds heal, it becomes easier to choose relationships that are genuinely loving rather than familiar but painful.

How therapy can support you

Therapy can help you:

  • Understand the difference between healthy connection and codependent patterns.
  • Explore how early experiences may be shaping current relationship choices.
  • Develop self-compassion instead of blaming themselves for “not being enough.”
  • Build practical skills in assertiveness, boundary-setting, emotional regulation, and self-care.
  • Gradually move toward relationships where they feel respected, valued, and chosen.

There is nothing “too broken” about wanting love, even if your patterns right now are painful or confusing.

With the right support, it is entirely possible to move from chasing rejection and clinging to unhealthy relationships, toward choosing — and accepting — relationships that are genuinely good for you.

If this article resonates with you, it may be a sign that you deserve a space to talk things through.

Asking one of our psychologists for help is not a sign of weakness; it is often the first step toward insight into and the potential to develop and experience a different kind of relationship — one where you no longer have to abandon yourself in order to feel loved.

Article is written with the assistance of Perplexity AI.

We’re here for you!

Join a thriving community of over 1,000 Australians who have improved their mental health with our support!

Latest Articles